CardFax

Grading Standards

Published. Versioned. Deterministic.

These are the exact standards the engine grades against. A grade issued is a grade kept — improvements to the standards apply to new gradings only and are never applied retroactively to cards already registered on the CardFax.

The Grade Scale

GradeNameRequirement
10Gem MintSubgrade average above 9.5
9MintSubgrade average of 9.0 or higher
8Near Mint-MintSubgrade average of 8.0 or higher
7Near MintSubgrade average of 7.0 or higher
6Excellent-MintSubgrade average of 6.0 or higher
5ExcellentSubgrade average of 5.0 or higher
4Very GoodSubgrade average of 4.0 or higher
3GoodSubgrade average of 3.0 or higher
2FairSubgrade average of 2.0 or higher
1PoorSubgrade average below 2.0

The Final Grade Formula

final_grade = min(

preliminary_grade, // average of 4Q™

lowest_subgrade_cap, // the weakest subgrade caps the ceiling

floor(surface_grade) // surface sets a hard floor cap

)

  • The lowest subgrade caps the grade. A card averaging 9.1 with an 8.9 subgrade tops out at 8 — one weak dimension can never hide behind three strong ones.
  • Surface sets a hard cap. The overall grade can never exceed the floor of the surface grade. A surface of 8.7 caps the card at 8.
  • Corners and edges are averages capped by their lowest member. Four corner grades of 9.5, 9.3, 9.0, and 8.7 average 9.125 — but the 8.7 caps the subgrade at 8.
  • Gem Mint 10 requires an average above 9.5. There is no rounding up.

Centering Standards

Front

60/40

Buffer standard — up to 10% deviation still measures a perfect 10.

Back

75/25

Buffer standard — up to 25% deviation still measures a perfect 10.

  • Weighting: front centering counts for 80% of the centering subgrade, back for 20%.
  • Graduated deductions: the first 10% of excess deviation deducts lightly, the next 10% deducts more steeply, and beyond 20% deductions are unlimited — severe miscuts fall off the cliff they deserve.
  • Diamond-cut detection: a corner-to- corner measurement delta above 3% flags a tilted cut and applies a tilt penalty.

Frequently Asked Questions

What grading scale does CardFax use?

The whole-grade Gem-Mint scale, 1 through 10: Gem Mint 10, Mint 9, Near Mint-Mint 8, and down the published ladder. Axis subgrades carry decimals; the final grade is derived from them by fixed arithmetic, never by feel.

How is the final grade calculated?

The four axis grades — centering, corners, edges, surface — are averaged, then held down by the weakest axis and capped by the surface floor. The weakest category governs: a card is only as good as its worst axis.

What centering counts as perfect?

The front is judged against a 60/40 tolerance — inside it, no deduction. Beyond the buffer, deductions grow in published tiers, and the back is held to a looser 75/25 standard at lower weight.

Do grading standards change over time?

The standards are versioned and published, and changes apply to new gradings only. A card graded under an earlier standard keeps its grade — regrading history to a new formula is forbidden by policy.